Buy It For Life
Pillows

Updated May 23, 2024

Buy it for life: the most durable pillows,
according to r/BuyItForLife on Reddit.
Recommended by people who have owned them for years. How we pick.
Do you know of an item that should be on this list? Let us know!

Coop Home Goods Pillow

A highly customizable shredded memory foam pillow that allows you to add or remove filling for personalized comfort.

Customizable
Long-lasting
Great support

Current one that I’ve found works for this picky pillow snob is the Coop Homegoods crescent shaped pillow.
– lifewithkermit

The pillow my wife and I have stuck with the longest is shredded memory foam. You can fluff it up like a down pillow.
– Sethjustseth

Second coop home goods.
– unknown

Purple Harmony Pillow

High-quality pillow with a unique grid design that provides excellent neck support and stays cool throughout the night.

Excellent neck support
Stays cool
Durable

I've personally found the Purple Harmony pillow to be a good investment.
– mnblade

I have one and love it.
– almazin

Absolutely agreed. Love my Purple Harmony, as a side sleeper myself.
– karmapuhlease

Buckwheat Pillow

An eco-friendly pillow filled with buckwheat hulls, known for its excellent support and customizable firmness.

Excellent support
Customizable firmness
Eco-friendly

Buckwheat pillows, for me! I was given my first one as a gift in the early 90’s, and I had it for over twenty years.
– alisimori

If you’re interested in something firm, I’m a big fan of my buckwheat pillow. Mine is from PineTales.
– IndianaJD

I have the curved pillow from Sleep Number and I absolutely love it.
– bitter98

Pillow Cube

Specialized pillow designed for side sleepers, with a unique cube shape providing optimal neck and spine alignment.

Optimal neck alignment
Designed for side sleepers

I've bought all the pillows everyone said to buy for neck pain.
– rfleming944

I’ve been using the Pillow Cube side sleeper for over a year and have had great success.
– Bobbsmomm

I think it’s a niche pillow. My partner absolutely hates it but for me it’s the perfect pillow for how I sleep.
– Faroffposition

Tempurpedic Neck Pillow

Ergonomically designed memory foam pillow providing exceptional neck support for side sleepers.

Exceptional neck support
Ergonomic design
Durable

I'm a side sleeper who has suffered with similar issues. Make sure you evaluate and consider changing your mattress as well.
– put_on_the_mask

Second tempurpedic though I prefer this one: https://www.tempurpedic.com/shop-pillows/symphony-pillow/
– zildjianfan

I love my tempurpedic neck pillow. I’ve had it for ~15 years.
– multilinear_alg

Frankenmuth Woolen Mill Pillows

High-quality wool pillows that provide excellent comfort and temperature regulation, produced using traditional methods.

Excellent comfort
Temperature regulation
Traditional quality

I love these soo much. Need to buy some more. I have one and my husband is jealous of me.
– Leroybird

I’ve been to the factory where they make these, it has a little shop inside. It’s pretty neat.
– pingusuperfan

I have their comforter and mattress topper. Aided with linen sheets and buckwheat pillow my sleep is as good as it gets.
– arcticrobot

Available at Frankenmuth Woolen Mill

Back to Bedding

Sources:
Wife and I need new pillows.
The pillow cube ain’t it
Best Pillow for Side Sleepers?
Finally replacing the rest of my pillows with Frankenmuth Woolen Mill pillows These pillows are unbelievable, 3 years and going strong on the first pair we got so why not exclusively use them? One of the few companies that has the same quality and production as 100 years ago! Comforters rock too!
Pillow for side sleepers?
Please Please Please Help Me Solve My Very Long, Very Dramatic Struggle With Pillows

Buy It For LifePillows